User talk:KingofFables: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
KingofFables (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Marblemadmax (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
Hello! I saw you re-spoilered some quest items which I'd removed spoiler tags for, specifically a few in the potato quests. I think we should phase out use of spoilers on these pages and I'd removed the ones I did because there's so little info otherwise in these articles, and they are only really linked to from the quest pages - if someone finds themselves on a quest item article it's because they're looking for some very specific info. Also - the spoiler table doesn't collapse for mobile users (which are more then 1/2 of visitors), but section headers do automatically. So their user flow is to click 'Use' anyway to toggle the info - but then they see 'spoiler' listed over and over for info that isn't actually spoilered. The template was never designed for quest pages to be used like this. I just wanted to discuss with you before rolling back edits/cleaning any of it up! -- [[User:Marblemadmax|Marblemadmax]] ([[User talk:Marblemadmax|talk]]) 19:17, 19 June 2023 (UTC) | Hello! I saw you re-spoilered some quest items which I'd removed spoiler tags for, specifically a few in the potato quests. I think we should phase out use of spoilers on these pages and I'd removed the ones I did because there's so little info otherwise in these articles, and they are only really linked to from the quest pages - if someone finds themselves on a quest item article it's because they're looking for some very specific info. Also - the spoiler table doesn't collapse for mobile users (which are more then 1/2 of visitors), but section headers do automatically. So their user flow is to click 'Use' anyway to toggle the info - but then they see 'spoiler' listed over and over for info that isn't actually spoilered. The template was never designed for quest pages to be used like this. I just wanted to discuss with you before rolling back edits/cleaning any of it up! -- [[User:Marblemadmax|Marblemadmax]] ([[User talk:Marblemadmax|talk]]) 19:17, 19 June 2023 (UTC) | ||
::Sorry about that. We put spoilers on quests so it wasn't clear what the best practices are for spoilers on the same info on quest items. But that's a good point and I will remove the spoiler tags. If you see any formatting inconsistencies like that and want to put them on the admin noticeboard or w/e, I can follow what the decision is. | ::Sorry about that. We put spoilers on quests so it wasn't clear what the best practices are for spoilers on the same info on quest items. But that's a good point and I will remove the spoiler tags. If you see any formatting inconsistencies like that and want to put them on the admin noticeboard or w/e, I can follow what the decision is. | ||
:::No need to apologize - none of this reasoning is listed as a policy anywhere and there were a bunch of articles using the spoilers already. Really appreciate your working to make the formatting consistent, and in this case it wasn't clear at all a standard layout -- [[User:Marblemadmax|Marblemadmax]] ([[User talk:Marblemadmax|talk]]) 01:53, 21 June 2023 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 01:53, 21 June 2023
Spoilers on Quest Items
Hello! I saw you re-spoilered some quest items which I'd removed spoiler tags for, specifically a few in the potato quests. I think we should phase out use of spoilers on these pages and I'd removed the ones I did because there's so little info otherwise in these articles, and they are only really linked to from the quest pages - if someone finds themselves on a quest item article it's because they're looking for some very specific info. Also - the spoiler table doesn't collapse for mobile users (which are more then 1/2 of visitors), but section headers do automatically. So their user flow is to click 'Use' anyway to toggle the info - but then they see 'spoiler' listed over and over for info that isn't actually spoilered. The template was never designed for quest pages to be used like this. I just wanted to discuss with you before rolling back edits/cleaning any of it up! -- Marblemadmax (talk) 19:17, 19 June 2023 (UTC)
- Sorry about that. We put spoilers on quests so it wasn't clear what the best practices are for spoilers on the same info on quest items. But that's a good point and I will remove the spoiler tags. If you see any formatting inconsistencies like that and want to put them on the admin noticeboard or w/e, I can follow what the decision is.
- No need to apologize - none of this reasoning is listed as a policy anywhere and there were a bunch of articles using the spoilers already. Really appreciate your working to make the formatting consistent, and in this case it wasn't clear at all a standard layout -- Marblemadmax (talk) 01:53, 21 June 2023 (UTC)
- Sorry about that. We put spoilers on quests so it wasn't clear what the best practices are for spoilers on the same info on quest items. But that's a good point and I will remove the spoiler tags. If you see any formatting inconsistencies like that and want to put them on the admin noticeboard or w/e, I can follow what the decision is.